Pies

Experience love at first bite with these delicious pie flavors we offer. Don't see anything you like? Give us your idea and we'll make your cravings come true!


Classic Apple Pie

This recipe has a super flaky crust and a perfectly seasoned apple pie filling.

Pecan Pie

It has a great buttery, vanilla infused filling and is topped with crunchy pecans.

Key Lime Pie

It has a creamy, tangy filling inside a great tasting graham cracker crust.

Chocolate Pie

Our chocolate pie has a super creamy chocolate pudding filing inside a crumbly graham cracker crust.

Lemon Meringue Pie

This refreshing pie has a tangy lemon custard filling and is topped with a light and fluffy meringue topping.

Caramel Pie

This delicious pie is topped with whipped cream, toffee and toasted pecans.

Cheesecake/Donuts/Pie Order Form

Prices are subject to change
If no mark n/a


Available year round
Menu changes seasonally, also varies based on ingredient availability
Please view our donut menu to see your choices

By clicking the above button, I consent to be contacted by Once Upon a Thyme Catering and Webit, Inc. at any email address or telephone number I provide, including, without limitation, communications sent via text message to my cell phone or communications sent using an autodialer or prerecorded message. This acknowledgement constitutes my written consent to receive such communications. I agree and consent to any applicable Terms and Conditions of Use or Privacy Policy available on this website.

Thanks! Your form has been sent.